ENHYPEN’s Jay is at the center of online debate following his appearance in a recently released dance challenge video with Daniela of rookie girl group KATSEYE.
The video, posted on May 1 via KATSEYE’s official social platforms, features the two idols dancing to “Gnarly,” KATSEYE’s latest hyper-pop track that has already been making waves for both its bold style and alleged AI usage.
While many fans were thrilled to see an unexpected interaction between artists from HYBE sub-labels, Jay’s reserved execution of the choreography quickly became a point of contention.
Some online critics argued that his movement lacked fluidity and energy, especially compared to Daniela’s expressive and vibrant performance.
Comments specifically targeted Jay’s minimal hip movement, with some claiming it undercut the mood of the dance.
However, the backlash sparked a wave of defense from fans and fellow netizens. Supporters highlighted that dance challenges are meant to be lighthearted and open to personal interpretation.
Some pointed out that male idols are sometimes given alternate choreography for stylistic or branding purposes and emphasized that nitpicking collaborative moments sends mixed signals—especially when fans are constantly asking for more inter-group interactions.
In fact, many came to Jay’s defense with posts saying:
“Y’all want idol interactions, then complain when it happens. Pick a struggle.”
“It’s just a dance challenge, not a performance. Let people have fun.”
“There’s nothing wrong with Jay’s version. Not everyone needs to perform in the same way.”
Despite the divided opinions, the video has continued to draw attention for bringing together two high-profile fourth-generation idols, adding fuel to both fan excitement and discourse around gendered expectations in K-pop choreography.
Do you think dance challenges should allow more freedom in expression, or is consistency with choreography important for fans?
